top of page

Why Isn't Couples Homework Helping My Relationship?

Nov 11
7 min read

Updated: 4 days ago

lady writing on paper at a table

You have gotten all the books, listened to the podcasts, watched the Instagram reels, received coaching with clever new ways to approach the places you and your partner/spouse get stuck in. You both come up with a strategy, know the right answers, done the research and have practiced some communication skills...


BUT your cycle keeps happening again, and again, and again.


The discouragement and fatigue is probably setting in, especially because you both may be in a place where you seemed to have tried it all. Maybe you have even gone to therapy in the past, but just feel this sense of failing because you both know the skills, but when you both get activated into this negative cycle, all the knowledge and tools go out the window as if they never existed.


I often tell my couples that there is a big difference between knowing and experiencing. In relationship repair, until the knowing can cross over into the experiencing, then healing (and literally healing your nervous system) won't be easy. It is beyond frustrating when we know all that we need to do, but when the moment comes it just doesn't happen.


In this blog I want to help give understanding for this stuck place and normalize this experience. You're not the only one in this place and you're not failing or just won't ever 'get it.' Rather, what your running into is your nervous systems' well designed ways to protect yourself in moments of relational crisis. There is hope to not just know what to do, but to also experience something new together.


It's not that you or the homework are the problem, it's that often times we aren't starting in the right place.


Reason #1 The Homework isn't Working: The safety isn't there in the relationship to install these skills in the moments you most need them.


Doing something new in the midst of a negative cycle is risky business, even if it's a positive new move. This is because often times we don't have enough inventory of experiences to draw from where we can say, 'this new move worked in the middle of our deepest pain!' Let's be real, if we try something new that's vulnerable and it doesn't work, we will probably feel ourselves descend into an even deeper pit of despair. That would feel WAY worse.


In these negative cycles our nervous system is shooting off many alarm bells tied to this threat of connection being lost with the one who matters most to us. Many naturally shift into modes of protection such as defending, blaming, withdrawing, etc. in an effort to be heard, understood and tended to. Many times our protections are saying, 'if I don't defend or explain, I'll never be understood and the strain between us will grow; if I don't withdraw and get space this is going to get worse and the distance will climb between us-we will just experience the hurt again.' These protective moves often have two functions: prevent the chasm in the relationship from growing and protect yourself from hurting more.


The ways our nervous systems know how to move in moments of relational disconnect are often born during childhood and significant life events prior to the current relationship. When the fear center of your brain (amygdala) hasn't had a new positive experience WHILE (not before, not after, but DURING) the alarm bells are going off in your nervous system, it is very hard to slow down enough to take the plunge of trying on the homework in a live cycle. In a moment when our nervous system is shouting to be tended to, homework can feel like we are having to jump across the chasm of the emotional grand canyon. I can picture my own nervous system slamming my brakes to an abrupt halt at a jump like that!


Why can homework have this effect? Because it is often leading us to be more attentive to our partner/spouse (which is where we need to be!), but without building safety first (or the metaphorical bridge in this grand canyon imagery) our protective parts are likely not going to feel safe 'abandoning' our deepest pain, to jump the canyon to our partner when the fears of failing and feeling more pain are quite glaring and appear imminent! It's not that homework and skills don't work and are bad, it's that sometimes homework requires us to take risks parts of us can't do yet during a cycle. It's too big of a jump and sometimes we just need to start in a different place.


I think of the safety and security in the relationship as if it's the prerequisite hardware to being able to install 'homework' type skills successfully into your relationship. The homework is meant to help establish safety, but it can be really hard to talk our protective parts of self into the application of those skills when a negative cycle is ramping up. This is also because recalling the homework requires the use of our executive functioning, and unfortunately, the executive functioning in our brain often goes offline when we are in a negative cycle! This is because in cycles, our body shifts into fight-flight-freeze-fawn and we begin operating from our fear center (amygdala), and our executive functioning starts to turn off.


So you might wonder, well how is one supposed to move past this dilemma? The answer is relational attunement. To settle again, a large part of what we need is relational attunement from a safe other.


If you find yourself stuck in these cycles, this is where utilizing a therapist trained in emotionally focused couples therapy can come in to help soften the cycle. To help deescalate the cycle, the therapist is trained to relationally attune to each partner to help regulate their nervous systems. From that place with the therapists support, couples can begin to open new path ways of connection in the places they feel deepest pain.


Reason #2 The Homework isn't Working: The homework is causing you to tune into the wrong channel.


Homework can sometimes lead us to miss the places we actually need to go to with our partner/spouse. Homework might unintentionally cause you to tune out the attachment channel, which is the place both partner's need to access in order to provide the relational attunement needed to settle.


Think of a radio. You might be wanting to listen to jazz music, but the next channel number is heavy metal. With a gentle nudge of the radio dial you could unintentionally end up on a completely different station than you intended to land on. You wanted calming jazz, but accidentally ended up on heavy metal. The two channels are SO close to each other, yet the experiences they provide are so vastly different. This picture might help in understanding homework too (I know it might feel like splitting hairs in this discussion!). Homework for couples communication is intended to bring connection, but if there isn't enough safety in the relationship to install that homework into moments of disconnection, homework can be that accidental nudge of the radio dial tuning you into a totally different channel and missing the attachment channel. The homework can seem SO close to the getting the attachement channel, but the experience could feel vastly different from being in the attachment channel itself.


Homework can also bring in the assumption that parts of ourself feel safe enough to take that kind of plunge and can lead us to totally missing the parts that are fearful and hesitant around trying something new in the cycle in the first place.


I often tell my clients that we only move as quickly as our protections allow us to. Homework can unintentionally lead to bypassing the need for the pain, fear and longings these protective moves carry to be heard for what they are trying to do for the relationship and the person. It is in this process of understanding the protective dance that we can help build trust with our protective parts that it's okay to take one little new step and begin building to a place where some of the homework skills can be introduced.


Reason #3 The Homework isn't Working: The Homework is too big of an emotional stretch.


Imagine if someone is working towards being able to touch their toes, but currently they can only touch their knees. If they are told their stretching homework is to touch their ankles, they aren't going to be able to do it. The stretch is too big. But if they start with touching their knees and stretch just a little further for what is possible for their bodies and they keep slowly adding to that, then one day they will get to touching their toes. That's kind of like homework, sometimes the homework is like asking someone to touch their ankles (to get to touching their toes) when they can only touch their knees. It's not that they can't ever get to touching their ankles and toes, but they need to start in a different place.


If you are able to take homework and apply it in a moment of disconnection and feel more closely bonded after, then that is great! You probably have more safety built in the relationship than you might realize. And that is something to celebrate! I also want you to know that if you feel stuck in any kind of homework and feel unsuccessful, that your experience is not abnormal. It just means the homework is probably too big of a stretch and we just need a different starting point.


So if the homework isn't working, where does a couple start?


Emotionally Focused Couples Therapy can be that alternative starting point in these scenarios. A therapist trained in EFCT understands that when a couple's cycle is not deescalated, the couple won't easily be able to provide the relational attunement to each other that is needed just yet. Therefore, the starting place of a trained EFCT therapist isn't to give you homework. Instead the focus is providing the attunement and coregulation needed for each individual in the cycle in order to open new opportunities for the couple to find each other again. As safety builds in the process, the therapist and couple can explore homework tailored to the couple's needs if that feels helpful. However, the therapist will first be attuning to what the next appropriate 'stretch' looks like for the couple in order to help them get to a place of safety and connection.


The one thing I want you to take away is that there isn't something wrong with you if the homework isn't working. You just need a different starting point. There is hope for you, your partner/spouse and your relationship in the places you feel most stuck.


If you feel stuck in your relationship cycle and don't know what to do next, feel free to contact me. I would love to help loosen the knot of your cycle together and help you both get back onto a path of finding each other again.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page